Bretton Woods Project - Critical voices on the World Bank and IMF

Jump to main content | Jump to sidebar | Jump to navigation menu



Bank health loans fail check-up

News|Bretton Woods Project|15 June 1999|update 13|url
print|email |bookmark FacebookTweet thisdel.icio.usDigg!Stumble UponRedditGoogle BookmarksYahoo Buzz

The World Bank's Operations Evaluation Unit recently criticised Bank loans for Health, Nutrition and Population (HNP). It rated only 60 per cent of completed HNP projects "satisfactory". The quality of the projects' economic analysis was found to average just 4.25 out of a possible 8 points, rising to 5 for the most recent projects.

Whilst most achieve their short-term physical objectives, only 44 per cent of completed projects are likely to be sustainable after completion, largely because appraisals underestimated recurrent costs or borrower willingness to finance them.

Bank staff fail to match projects' technical specifications with the institutional environment or views of key stakeholders, including people who will have to implement the projects.

The evaluation notes that

"in public statements the Bank increasingly acknowledges the importance of beneficiary participation in project design and implementation ... [yet] OED identified only four projects where beneficiaries were given decision-making power".

The evaluation recommends piloting small "learning" initiatives to test interventions and build partnerships, but points out institutional constraints which push the Bank and borrowers to approve single large projects. These are: the desire to minimize transaction costs, the lack of resources for supervision and learning efforts and an incentive system which rewards good intentions rather than measurable results. Indeed the evaluation says that "the past record [of measuring the outcomes of investments] is discouraging at best".

The December 1998 HNP Evaluation is not available from the Bank itself, but can be obtained from the Bank Information Center, 733 15th Street, NW, Suite 1126, Washington DC 20005, USA, bicusa@igc.org or the Bretton Woods Project.

Published: 15 June 1999 , last edited: 12 February 2009

Viewings since posted: 4295

Articles: 3798

Advanced article search
Search newswire and resources

Recent briefings & reports

Climate Investment Funds Monitor 7: April 2013  25 April 2013

Working paper: The private sector and climate change adaptation: International Finance Corporation investments under the Pilot Program for Climate Resilience  24 April 2013

The UK's role in the World Bank and IMF: Department for International Development and HM Treasury  13 March 2013

World Bank on jobs: a "significant departure" or "business as usual"? 13 February 2013

The World Bank and industrial policy: Hands off or hands on? 6 December 2012

Climate Investment Funds Monitor 6: October 2012   26 October 2012

Latest video from IFIwatch.tv

The awakening of the squares 20 May

Subscribe

Bretton Woods Update, 6 emails/year:
highlights fulltext pdf
Alerts of new web content
Weekly newswire email

Email:


Bretton Woods Project on Facebook


home | subscribe | donate | search | help | contact


validate: | XHTML | CSS | RSS | 508

powered by Action Apps | hosted by GreenNet | Credits