Menu

Bretton Woods Project

Critical voices on the world bank and IMF

Advanced search »
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • Topics
    • Accountability
    • Conditionality
    • Environment
    • Finance
    • Gender
    • IFI governance
    • Infrastructure
    • Knowledge
    • Land
    • Private Sector
    • Rights
    • Social services
    • Trade
    • WB/IMF roles
  • Institutions
    • International Monetary Fund (IMF)
    • Other
    • Other International Financial Institutions
    • UK Government
    • UN
    • World Bank Group
  • Countries
    • East Asia & Pacific
    • Eastern Europe & Central Asia
    • International
    • Latin America & Caribbean
    • Middle East & North Africa
    • North America
    • South Asia
    • Sub-Saharan Africa
    • Western Europe
  • Publications
    • Observer
    • Dispatch
    • News Lens
    • Briefings
    • Analysis
    • Commentary
    • Background
    • Reports
    • Other
      • Bulletin
      • Update
      • CIFs Monitor
  • About Us
    • About the Bretton Woods Project
    • Staff profiles
    • Project Steering Group
    • Annual reports
    • Project news
    • Job opportunities
    • en
    • es
  • Finance
  • Finance

From issue 67 of The Bretton Woods Update

Related articles

Debate asiático sobre la retirada del FMI y del Occidente

1 October 2009

Finance

News

Asia debates moving away from IMF and West

22 September 2009

by Bhumika Muchhala

By Bhumika Muchhala, Third World Network

At a conference in Penang, Malaysia in August, officials, academics and members of civil society from the Asian region sought to chart a way towards greater regional cooperation that would insulate them from the IMF and financial crises.

The conference on effects of the global financial crisis on Asian developing countries, organised by Third World Network and the Consumers Association of Penang, brought together present and former central bankers, finance ministry officials, researchers and civil society organisations. A strong theme was the need to develop regional consumption, trade and investment rather than relying on debt-laden consumers in the developed world.

painfully clear that the IMF solution is bankrupt

Looking at the recent developments to the Chiang Mai Initiative (see Update 66) and the prospect of reviving the idea of an Asian Monetary Fund, Andrew Sheng, former chairman of the Hong Kong Securities Commission and now a chief advisor to China’s Banking Regulatory Commission, said there are three choices for Asia: to stick to the status quo; take defensive measures and cooperate to avoid damage; or take an offensive approach including forcing international reforms.  He said Asia is now somewhere between the status quo and the defensive approach.  While the Asian financial crisis made it painfully clear to Asian countries that the IMF solution is bankrupt, the present crisis has also shown the lack of creative and collective thinking at the regional level.

Former governor of India’s central bank, YV Reddy, agreed with Sheng that Asia should not be defensive, as the region has 67 per cent of the world’s currency reserves, 55 per cent of the world’s population and a significant share of global production.  He suggested that an influential Asian think-tank be established to provide advice on finance to policymakers, and that Asia should act to rebalance the global financial system.  For example, there are only two credit rating agencies and two financial news agencies with global influence, all of which are Western-owned.  Similar agencies should be set up by Asians, using the perspective of developing countries, he said.

Pitchaya Sirivunnabood, from the Fiscal Policy Research Institute in the Thai Ministry of Finance, felt that Asia’s financial clout from trade surpluses and high reserve holdings inspired more aggressive ideas for financial cooperation, for example an Asian currency unit.  She noted that one of the priorities of the Chiang Mai Initiative is the development of a surveillance system, independent of the IMF. This would support the decision-making of the initiative’s secretariat and could facilitate the eventual de-linking from IMF programmes.  Currently, Chiang Mai Initiative funds are still linked to IMF programmes beyond an initial amount of financing.

Yilmaz Akyüz, special economic advisor to the South Centre, an intergovernmental body based in Geneva, said that Asia meets the criteria for developing a common currency just as much as the European Union at the time of the initial work on the euro. Akyüz said that in the past, financial integration in Asia had been stifled by the unconstructive intervention of the IMF and other international actors.  “But this time Asia is really serious,” he said, “The European Monetary Union took years to create, and Asia has to move in a similar direction.”

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related articles

Debate asiático sobre la retirada del FMI y del Occidente

1 October 2009

Subscribe

Get our alerts and publications in your inbox

Share

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Advocacy Programs

  • Gender Equality & Macroeconomics project
  • Environmental advocacy

World Bank & IMF in the news

Accountability

News

16 March 2023

IFC policy for when projects cause harm lambasted as ‘letdown’

Devex

IFI governance

Analysis

16 March 2023

Biden’s pick for World Bank president can’t fix its crisis

Al Jazeera

Environment

News

15 March 2023

IMF approves first batch of climate resilience loans

Climate Home

Private Sector

News

9 March 2023

World Bank’s scandal-hit ‘Doing Business’ seeks redemption with revamp

Devex
More news

Featured briefings

8 December 2022

The Bretton Woods Observer: Winter 2022

6 October 2022

World Bank and IMF Annual Meetings 2022

4 October 2022

The Bretton Woods Observer: Autumn 2022

More briefings

Donate

Donate to the Bretton Woods Project

Twitter

My Tweets
This website uses cookies. By using this website you agree to their use. More information

CONTENT

  • Open letters
  • Events
  • FAQ
  • Glossary
  • Resources

SUBSCRIBE

  • Subscribe by email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS feeds

HELP

  • Privacy policy
  • Accessibility policy
  • Credits
  • Help
  • Contact us