Gender

Background

Women, work and the economy

10 October 2013 | Minutes

IMF/WB Civil Society Forum

Thursday 10 October 2013

Panellists

  • Kalpana Kochar; Deputy Director Strategy Policy and Review Department IMF
  • Prof Jennifer Klein, Adjunct Prof of Law, Georgetown University
  • Chair: Nisreen Farhan, IMF

Presentations

Kalpana Kochar – Presentation on the Macro Gains form Gender Equity

How can IMF work on this – acknowledging how circumscribed IMF is in terms of its core mandate.

Female labour force participation rates remain low in many countries, and have stagnated at low levels worldwide on average.

Gender gaps in participation rates remain high, looking at 1990 to 2010, though the gender gaps have declined in that period for the majority of regions.

Often the cause of narrowing gaps is actually the decline in male participation rates, which is hardly the best way to reduce the gender gap.

Why is this an IMF issue? Because low female participation rates can have significant macroeconomic stability implications.

Through the IMF surveillance process in Article IV reports, we have pointed out where the gender gap remains large, such as recent cases in Japan, S Korea and Saudi Arabia.

Because of the access that the IMF has to country authorities, we know we can contribute to the gender equity agenda by bringing the big picture by not involving more women in the labour force and levelling the playing field.

We can also work with the Bank, ILO and others to generate the relevant data. Currently the impact of policies is not sufficiently measured in a way that delineates gender.

Third, we can help on fiscal policy – apart from macro this is a core area of IMF work.

ILO estimates suggest 865 million women can contribute more fully to national economies.

How?

Higher female labour force participation could boost economic growth by mitigating the impact of a shrinking workforce. Greater opportunities to control and earn income amongst women suggests that – based on extensive evidence – leads to higher school enrolment for children and stronger human capital. Equal access to inputs can improve productivity in female owned companies. Equally based employment of women leads to a general improvement in the talent pool.

Evidence from WB’s gender WDR showed huge income losses due to gender gap in different regions, e.g. MENA 27%, the lowest being Sub-Saharan Africa which is still high at 12%.

Japan is a key case. Its population is aging very rapidly, which seems to be on the verge of a declining population. Despite very high educational attainment amongst women, there remains very low participation rate. Were the participation rate at the OECD average it would yield 4% increase in GDP, and if it had the N European average its gains in per capita income would be almost double that.

This has led to the PM in Japan make increasing labour force participation a key plank of his growth strategy.

How can policies work?

An integrated set of policies is needed, though IMF focus is on the core expertise of the Fund, fiscal, but this is not to suggest that other key factors are not as if not more critical. Note that cultural factors are at play, but the potential and economic inefficiency is still present, e.g. in Saudi Arabia women’s educational attainment far outstrips that of men.

Tax Measures

Replace family income taxation with individual income taxation.

Secondary earners are mostly women. Female labour supply is more response to taxation than male labour supply.  Female labour supply is more responsive to taxation.

Expenditure Measures

Publicly financed parental leave schemes – e.g. Brazil may be a great example of this. Greater parity in paternity and maternity leave.

Improved access to comprehensive, affordable and high-quality child care

Pensions: ensure spells from maternity leave do not penalize via lower pensions. Higher spending on education of women, and improvements in rural infrastructure. The latter is supported by Bank and other evidence shows that access to infrastructure ends up freeing up time previously occupied by time-consuming basic tasks which are low-productivity.

Prof Jennifer Klein

Focus on the constraints facing women seeking to enter the labour force. In addition to those set out already there are economic constraints, from access to capital, skills and women’s leadership.

The pay gap remains a huge issue, in the US it remains 76 cents to every dollar men earn, which hasn’t changed in a decade. In OECD states it is a 16% gap.

Health disparities also prevail, and the number one killer of girls from 15 to 19 remains complications related to childbirth.

These issues are therefore broad, and not just in the realm of the IMF.

There are changes afoot, and gender equality and status of women and girls is increasingly discussed.

Under-secretary of state Clinton, the first attempt at gender integration in foreign policy, which led to a real examination of what the department and US AID was doing. Policy guidance led to examination of gender in multiple areas, such as gender assessments in strategic planning.

The record of Secretary Clinton, dating back to 1995, is extensive and very focused on ensuring the engagement of the private sector.

This issue remains a moral imperative, and an issue of fairness. What’s changed perhaps in the last 5 years is that it’s increasingly seen as a smart policy, for security, stability, and prosperity.

Discussion

Elaine Zuckerman, Gender Action

For the last dozen years, we’ve critiqued the IMF across these issues, and I do feel a huge sea change given the IMF is discussing things such as equal parental leave. The IMF has finally gone beyond the Consensus it occupied.

What I hope that Article IV and advice to LICs and other states begins to incorporate this into its work in programme countries

Pam Gomez, ITUC

The work is very useful and the efforts made are thoughtful, and the policy implications remain very well thought out, so we welcome this paper.

Thinking about the IMF, at the moment there remains only one woman on the IMF board – what are your thoughts on that and other institutions’ leadership?

Sargon Nissan, Bretton Woods Project

What are the plans to operationalise the lessons in this paper, in particular in assessing and developing gender disaggregated data in terms of programme countries.

Kalpana Kochar

This work is linked to the broader agenda of jobs and growth.  A major board paper was issued in Feb/March this year, with an accompanying guidance note which sets out how to take gender into account. WE will issue a guidance note to staff, and plan to do some ‘in-reach’ which takes this work to the departments which conduct missions, but also reflect to them what data is already available, despite the gaps that do persists, including Bank studies about issues of women and the law and rights to property.

One effective method of persuasion is to compare and contrast countries’ performance. This is difficult for us to achieve, except perhaps in terms of programme countries.

Regarding women’s leadership, this partly reflects pipeline problems in recruitment that has only recently become fully balanced. One approach is to champion the progress of women into leadership.

There was a previous period when we did very well in recruitment but not so well in seeing their progress through the ranks, so this was brought to the attention of management and HR practices began to adjust to reflect this.

Nisreen Farhar

Regarding leadership, the Exec Directors are elected by governments and they are choosing to send so few women.

 

 

More background on this issue

Gender

Background

15 November 2019 | Minutes

Advancing a feminist approach to women's economic inequality

Notes from the Civil Society Policy Forum panel event on 16 October on women's economic inequality and macroeconomic policy.

Gender

Background

28 October 2019 | Minutes

Cutting to the core: Rethinking the IMF’s way of doing business to tackle gender inequalities

Notes from the Civil Society Policy Forum panel event on 17 October on the IMF’s approach to gender.

Gender

Background

18 April 2019 | Minutes

Sexual orientation & gender identity – considering risk mitigation within World Bank programming

Finance

Background

16 April 2019 | Minutes

Taxes, Taxes, Taxes: Shifting the IFI Narrative to Progressive Gender-just Taxation

Notes from the Civil Society Policy Forum session on 12 April on the changing international tax landscape from a feminist perspective and challenging IFIs’ role in shaping it at the World Bank and IMF's 2019 Spring Meetings.

Gender

Background

11 October 2017 | Minutes

Contradicting commitments: Why fiscal space matters for women and work

Notes from the 2017 World Bank and IMF Annual Meetings session on the IMF's approach to fiscal space, women and work, 11 October

Gender

Background

15 April 2016 | Minutes

Missing the bigger picture for women’s economic empowerment? Wages, labor and taxation policies in focus

Notes from a meeting at the IMF/World Bank CSO Forum at the 2016 Spring meetings, exploring human rights, social policy and gender equality, examining the IMF’s pilot surveillance work on inequality and gender and the World Bank’s new gender strategy.

Gender

Background

8 October 2015 | Minutes

Mind the gaps: Toward a new World Bank Group gender equality strategy

Notes from the 8 October session of the World Bank gender strategy at the IMF and World Bank Annual Meetings CSO Policy Forum 2015.

Gender

Background

16 April 2015 | Minutes

Gender and development: What is happening now?

Notes from a meeting on gender and development during the World Bank spring meetings.

IFI governance

Background

16 March 2015 | Minutes

UK civil society meeting with UK World Bank Executive Director Gwen Hines

Notes of a meeting with UK World Bank Executive Director Gwen Hines 25 February 2015.

IFI governance

Background

10 October 2014 | Minutes

UK civil society meeting with UK World Bank Executive Director Gwen Hines

Notes of a meeting with World Bank executive director Gwen Hines in October 2014.

Infrastructure

Background

9 April 2014

Energy sector trends

Social services

Background

9 April 2014

Ensuring the Bank’s investment in and prioritisation of reproductive health up to 2015 and beyond

IFI governance

Background

8 April 2014

CSO roundtable with World Bank Group executive directors

Gender

Background

10 October 2013 | Minutes

Women, work and the economy

Infrastructure

Background

23 April 2013 | Minutes

Colombia case study: results measurement and poverty eradication

This session examined Colombia's private sector partnerships and poverty eradication programme.

IFI governance

Background

23 April 2013 | Minutes

The private sector and poverty eradication

This session gave an overview on the links between private sector and healthcare provision in tackling poverty.

IFI governance

Background

22 April 2013 | Minutes

Bending the arc of poverty

The session focused on the World Bank's development strategy, poverty eradication goals, global inequality, and the threat of climate change.

IFI governance

Background

22 April 2013 | Minutes

Financial and housing crises, the Bank's safeguards and the right to adequate housing

This session featured a presentation from UN special rapporteur on the links between financial and housing crises, safeguards and the right to adequate housing.

IFI governance

Background

22 April 2013 | Minutes

The challenges of advancing sustainability at the World Bank

This panel discussion reflected on the major sustainability challenges facing the World Bank through exploring two World Resources Institute areas - a portfolio analysis on 2012 projects, and the interaction between country systems and World Bank safeguard approaches.

IFI governance

Background

19 April 2013 | Minutes

World Bank executive directors roundtable with CSOs

Minutes of an open roundtable with EDs that occurred during the 2013 spring meetings.

Land

Background

19 April 2013 | Minutes

An update and briefing on the global agriculture and food security program (GAFSP)

World Bank briefing on the Global Agriculture and Food Security Program (GAFSP) with a particular focus on recent private sector window projects.

Finance

Background

19 April 2013 | Minutes

IDA results and replenishment

Minutes of an event at the 2013 spring meetings

IFI governance

Background

23 April 2012 | Minutes

EIR + 10

Minutes of afternoon sessions of extractives conference, Washington DC, 23 April 2012

Conditionality

Background

23 April 2012 | Minutes

A Global Shared Societies Agenda

Minutes meeting for A Global Shared Societies Agenda

Gender

Background

26 September 2011 | Minutes

Seminar - Gender and Infrastructure: Exploring the Nexus

Notes of meeting, Washington DC, September 23

Gender

Background

26 September 2011 | Minutes

Civil Society Strategy Meeting on the Doing Business rankings

Notes of a meeting, Washington DC, 21 September 2011

Gender

Background

23 September 2011 | Minutes

Seminar - Gender Equality Matters: The Way Forward

Notes of meeting, Washington DC, September 21, 2011

Land

Background

19 September 2011 | Minutes

Notes of meeting between Minister Alan Duncan, the UK Department for International Development and C

Meeting notes

IFI governance

Background

15 September 2011 | Minutes

Notes of meeting between UK Executive Director to World Bank and Civil Society Groups

Civil society organisations met UK Executive Director to the World Bank and staff from the Department for International Development to discuss water, the Bank's private sector approach, health and nutrition, safeguards review and energy strategy.

Land

Background

12 April 2011 | Minutes

Gender, IFIs and the global food crisis

Notes of a panel discussion, Washington DC, 12 April 2011

Gender

Background

5 April 2011 | Inside the institutions

The World Bank's approach to gender mainstreaming

The World Bank's current approach to gender mainstreaming promotes women's empowerment as "smart economics" that serves a dual equality-development purpose. This approach, which largely ignores non-economic sources of gender inequality, has been criticised for its narrow, market-driven focus.

Environment

Background

8 October 2009 | Minutes

CSO Townhall meeting

Notes from the CSO townhall meeting with Dominique Strauss-Kahn and Robert Zoellick

IFI governance

Background

22 September 2009 | Inside the institutions

Safeguard policies and performance standards

Originally drafted as internal operational policies to guide staff, World Bank safeguard policies evolved after pressure from environmental and social groups in the 1980s and were first officially implemented in 1998. They aim to protect people and the environment from the adverse effects of Bank-financed operations and are based on international agreements, even if these protections are not explicitly provided for in the borrower country's national law.

Gender

Background

23 January 2006 | Inside the institutions

The World Bank and education

brief summary of the World Bank's work and priorities in education

Environment

Background

28 June 2005 | Minutes

Highlights of meeting between Tom Scholar and UK NGOS

Highlights of meeting between Tom Scholar and UK NGOS

Latest articles on this issue

Gender

Analysis

IMF’s recognition of unpaid care work undermined by its own harmful policy advice

New IMF working paper establishes macro-criticality of unpaid care work but remains blind to Fund’s negative policy impacts on women and girls.

12 December 2019 | Guest analysis

Gender

Analysis

Keeping the IMF accountable to women's rights and gender equality at the national level

New IMF gender guidance opportunity for civil society to keep its staff to account.

18 November 2019 | Briefings

Gender

Background

Advancing a feminist approach to women's economic inequality

Notes from the Civil Society Policy Forum panel event on 16 October on women's economic inequality and macroeconomic policy.

15 November 2019 | Minutes

Gender

Background

Cutting to the core: Rethinking the IMF’s way of doing business to tackle gender inequalities

Notes from the Civil Society Policy Forum panel event on 17 October on the IMF’s approach to gender.

28 October 2019 | Minutes

Gender

Analysis

The World Bank and gender equality

Critical gender analysis of Bank's Development Policy Financing.

15 August 2019 | Briefings

Gender

News

World Bank’s women entrepreneur initiatives just “smoke and mirrors”

As We-Fi launches regional West Africa summit, feminists criticise narrow focus of women entrepreneur initiatives, while funding for women’s rights is in decline.

30 July 2019

Gender

News

Civil society left unconvinced as World Bank promotes PPPs as tool for gender equality

The World Bank launches a new primer on PPPs and gender equality as civil society and women’s rights groups highlight concerns around risks and harmful impacts to gender equality and sustainable development.

30 July 2019

Gender

Background

Sexual orientation & gender identity – considering risk mitigation within World Bank programming

This Civil Society Policy Forum Session was co-sponsored by the National LGBT Chamber of Commerce,…

18 April 2019 | Minutes

Finance

Background

Taxes, Taxes, Taxes: Shifting the IFI Narrative to Progressive Gender-just Taxation

Notes from the Civil Society Policy Forum session on 12 April on the changing international tax landscape from a feminist perspective and challenging IFIs’ role in shaping it at the World Bank and IMF's 2019 Spring Meetings.

16 April 2019 | Minutes

Gender

Analysis

Gender-Just Macroeconomics II

BWP's Gender and Macroeconomics project launches a booklet on Gender-Just Macroeconomics; the World Bank’s privatisation push

11 March 2019 | Briefings