Surviving the pipeline? A critical analysis of the WBG’s policy approach to gender equality and macroeconomic reform through the lending process
•
Article summary
New BWP analysis reveals that while gender considerations are increasingly integrated into the World Bank diagnostics and strategies, they often sit alongside policy reforms centred on fiscal consolidation, privatisation, social protection targeting, public-private partnerships and private sector-led development, which this report demonstrates can have a negative impact on gender equality.
The World Bank Group (WBG), which positions itself as a world-leading expert on gender equality in international development, has expanded its commitment to gender equality over the past decade. Through the Gender Strategy 2024–2030, the institution presents gender equality as an “urgent imperative” that is “essential” for development, and commits to addressing barriers facing women and girls through investments in areas such as human capital, economic opportunities and leadership.
Drawing on the analysis of ten countries using a dedicated benchmarking system, new research by BWP’s Gender Equality and Macroeconomics Project, follows gender priorities through the World Bank’s policy pipeline, from Systematic Country Diagnostics (SCDs) and Country Partnership Frameworks (CPFs) to Development Policy Financing (DPF) operations. The findings reveal a persistent contradiction: while gender considerations are increasingly integrated into diagnostics and strategies, they often sit alongside policy reforms centred on fiscal consolidation, privatisation, social protection targeting, public-private partnerships and private sector-led development, which this report demonstrates can have a negative impact on gender equality.
Recommendations
- Adopt a ‘do no harm’ approach to all macroeconomic policy advice, including mandatory ex-ante and post hoc distributional impact assessments, with a gender lens, for all loans disbursed under DPL.
- Ensure all World Bank policy advice and lending operations are consistent with international human rights commitments, including CEDAW, the Beijing Platform for Action and the Sustainable Development Goals. Develop a WBG human rights policy framework.
- Strengthen and standardise the use of Poverty and Social Impact Assessments (PSIAs) across the policy pipeline. Adopt a formal definition of what constitutes “significant poverty and social consequences”, including in relation to gender equality and women’s economic empowerment. Require all DPF prior actions to be assessed through PSIAs that explicitly consider gendered impacts.
- Adopt long standing calls to apply social and environmental safeguard principles to Development Policy Financing (DPF) to ensure policy-based lending is subject to robust assessment of social, gender and human rights risks.
- Undertake a comprehensive independent evaluation of the WBG’s approach to Private Capital Mobilisation to assess the degree to which it results in outcomes detrimental to women and girls’ rights and gender equality more broadly.
- Move beyond labour force participation targets towards a gender-transformative jobs agenda grounded in decent work, care and social protection.
This report will be presented and discussed with members of civil society and the World Bank’s gender team as part of the WBG & IMF Annual Meetings’ Civil Society Policy Forum. More details about the session, participants, etc, can be found here. The recording of this session will be posted on this page once available.
This research has been developed by Fiana Arbab and GEM Project Joint Coordinator Amy McShane as part of BWP Gender Equality and Macroeconomics Project. To learn more about this report or BWP’s GEM project more broadly, please click below.
